Due to COVID-19, in-store cake tasting appointments are suspended indefinitely. You can pick up a tasting box to enjoy at home and then follow up with our wedding coordinators to design your dream cake. 

Cake Tasting Boxes are $15.

Click on the "Book Now" link for your selected store at the bottom of this page to order yours today!

Getting Married? Congratulations!

Butter + Cream specializes in beautiful custom wedding cakes. We recommend that you come in for a cake tasting and consultation 3-6 months before your wedding. You will be able to sit down with one of our coordinators and design the cake of your dreams. Expect your consultation to run anywhere from 25 minutes to 45 minutes.

All wedding cakes include a complimentary one year anniversary cake.


Many weddings or larger events include smaller desserts for guest tables or a dessert bar. Our different packages are a great way to provide a variety of treats for your guests so that everyone can enjoy something sweet. *We do not set up the tables, the desserts are either picked up or delivered to the venue in boxdes.

Dessert Package #1

-One 8" cutting cake

-3 flavors of cupcakes

$4.95 per guest


Dessert Package #2

-One 8" cutting cake

-2 flavors of cupcakes

-2 flavors of cookies

$4.95 per guest


Dessert Package #3

-A single layer cookie cake

-4 flavors of cookies

$4.95per guest

Image by Wendy Rueter

This package includes:

A dessert bar with an assortment of up to 4 types of desserts.


$6.95 per guest

Dessert Package #4




Mini Eclairs

Mini Fruit Tarts

Mini Creampuffs

Mini Brownies

Mini Lemon Tarts


Wedding Cake Tastings